Investigation proves India’s vaping ban a total failure


“This is the largest independent investigation we have seen in India since its 2019 vaping ban. It shows a damning call for the government to lift the ban and regulate access to basic products. safer nicotine, ”said Nancy Loucas, executive coordinator of the Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA).

His comments follow the publication of a “Survey of Current and Former Smoke-Free Users: India” conducted by Povaddo – a company specializing in global public opinion research. The investigation was commissioned by consumer advocacy group Fact Asia.

“The Indian government needs to urgently reconsider its ban on vaping which is clearly not working. Indians continue to seek alternatives to smoking, but they are forced to return to smoking or black market with unregulated vaping products. It is a terrible public health situation for the inhabitants of the populated subcontinent, ”says Ms. Loucas.

Povaddo’s latest investigation confirms tremendous pressure for the Indian government to adopt a tobacco harm reduction (THR) approach instead. Conducted from August 30 to September 7, 2021, the survey involved 2,000 respondents across India – all current and former smoke-free users of legal age.

Almost nine in 10 respondents – or 86% – believe that products like e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products are a better alternative to cigarettes. Additionally, 87% believe that alternative products like e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products should be just as accessible to adult smokers as regular cigarettes.

Such equal access could lead to a decrease in the number of smokers. Among current users of cigarettes or other tobacco products, 92% say they would consider switching to an alternative smoke-free product if it was legal, met quality and safety standards, and was readily available.

A staggering 95% of those polled believe the government should come up with new ways to reduce the harm caused by cigarette smoking, with 81% of current and former users of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products saying the government should lift the ban on these products. .

The investigation also confirmed the total ineffectiveness of the ban. Following India’s 2019 ban on safer smokeless products, most users have not stopped using the products. In fact, 85% of all respondents reported being smoke-free before and after the ban. Dual users are also prolific in India with 92% of current users of smokeless products also using cigarettes.

“Ignoring the evidence, the Indian government adopted the poisoned anti-vaping advice of the World Health Organization (WHO), and now its people are paying a huge price. Over the past couple of years, Indians have been forced to either resume smoking to death, or consume unregulated street vapers, or both! While such results were unfortunately predictable, it is not too late. We call on the Indian government to take a close look at the detailed results of this investigation and to repeal its failed vaping ban, ”she said.

CAPHRA says India is leading the pack in the Asia-Pacific on how to misapply THR health policies, with Thailand, Australia and Hong Kong not far behind.

This happens despite the fact that India is home to 12% of smokers in the world. About 34.6% of Indian adults are smokers, with nearly 1.35 million Indians dying each year from smoking-related illnesses.

“Despite India’s appalling smoking record, it was truly outrageous that the WHO awarded India’s Minister of Health, Dr Harsh Vardhan, a special prize this year for banning e-cigarettes and the products. heated tobacco much less harmful, ”said Heneage Mitchell, founding director of Fait Asia.

“The WHO and the Indian government say they have been so successful in controlling tobacco use, but it is now clear that things have only gotten worse since the vaping ban. We are proud to have brought to light India’s epic failure in commissioning this major independent inquiry, ”said Mr. Mitchell.

Nancy Loucas: “Rather than blindly following the corrupt and unqualified advice of the WHO, the Indian government should introduce progressive vaping legislation proportionate to the risk, such as that adopted by New Zealand last year and that Filipino senators are now considering. This is how you reduce smoking-related illnesses and deaths. Bans don’t work and now we have more evidence.

“Not only has the Indian government succumbed to the lies of the WHO, but it has allowed American billionaire Michael Bloomberg to influence his national health policies. India did not fight so hard for independence in 1947 as it is now taking a step back and having foreign entities meddle in its government and its people, ”Ms. Loucas said.

The latest research proving that billionaire anti-smoking foundations have channeled millions of people to Asia-Pacific NGOs to pressure governments to ban vaping and discredit vaping advocates has drawn the attention of the world press. To see the full results and the money leads, visit:

Now live and with over 14,000 testimonials, CAPHRA calls on those who have quit smoking through smokeless nicotine alternatives to tell their story at

Consumer groups in the Asia-Pacific region have also launched a petition to He urges WHO to respect consumer rights and stop demonizing THR options before the ninth session of the Conference of the Parties (COP9) to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) in November.

© Scoop Media

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.